Nannie Embrey's Pizzelles

Christmas wasn't Christmas without Nannie's pizzelles when we got together with the extended family.  When we were married almost 40 years ago, Nannie, my mother-in-law, gifted me with a new pizzelle iron and gave me her recipe which I've been making every year.  These pizzelles are super thin and fragile and I find that storing them stacked in a tin that is a little wider than they are is the best way to store them.

We were faced with a dilemma a few years ago when Gloria joined our family.  Gloria, a 30 year old Amazon parrot, caused me to have to rethink much of what I do in the kitchen because the fumes from non stick cookware can kill a parrot in short order.  The pizzelle iron had a nonstick coating.  What to do!  I thought that if it wasn't TOO cold, I could make them out on the deck but I really didn't want to be standing in 40 degree weather trying to do that.  A little research led me to the original Cucina Pro pizzelle iron which is made out of aluminum.  Problem solved.  Now pizzelle making may resume on schedule with the nonstick appliance being passed to my son. You will need to follow the instructions on your own pizzelle maker.  I find that  usually have to throw away the first two as they are the test ones!  I hope you enjoy these as much as we do!

Nannie Embrey’s Pizzelles

Printable Recipe

Ingredients:

3 eggs, beaten

¾ cup sugar

¾ cup butter, melted

¾ - 1 cup flour

1 tsp. Baking powder

2 tsp. Anise extract

1 tsp. Vanilla 

Add and beat ingredients together in order listed--using the smaller 

amount of flour for thinner pizzelle.  Batter should be thick but flow 

from a spoon. Place about one tablespoon of batter in the center of 

both section of preheated pizzelle iron.  Close lid. Allow to cook 

until steaming stops -- about 30 - 60 seconds. Remove with fork.  

Allow to cool on wire rack or towels.  While hot, they may be rolled 

into a cylinder or shaped into cones.  Dust with confectioners’ sugar.  

Store in airtight container.  

Makes 2 dozen

Lemon variation:  Omit vanilla and anise extract.  

Add 1 teaspoon lemon extract and 1 tablespoon 

grated lemon peel to batter.

Note:   It will take a couple of tries to get the cooking time right.  My most recent batch took 40 seconds each time.  Also-- a 1 tablespoon cookie scoop makes easy work of scooping the batter onto the pizzelle baker.  With my Cuchina machine, you place the batter just a little toward the back of center.  Experiment to find what works with you. I place paper towels on a cooling rack and place the hot pizzelles there before stacking them in a tin.  Having your confectioners' sugar in a shaker or sifter gives a nice even coat.